CanucksArmy has no direct affiliation to the Vancouver Canucks, Canucks Sports & Entertainment, NHL, or NHLPA

Canucks vs. Red Wings: A sharp contrast in off-ice decision-making

Canucks vs. Red Wings: A sharp contrast in off-ice decision-making
Photo credit: Bob Frid for IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect
Stephan Roget
Nov 19, 2026, 12:30 ESTUpdated: Nov 19, 2026, 12:00 EST
It’s difficult to say how well the Vancouver Canucks are walking their current path. Rebuilds are such a long-term proposition that it’s almost impossible to gauge their success in the short term. All the Canucks can really do right now is to measure their current progress against the status of other teams in somewhat similar situations. And on that front, there’s a very sharp contrast available in the Detroit Red Wings.
For every positive step the Canucks have seemed to take in the right direction, the Red Wings have seemed to match with one in the wrong direction. In fact, the parallels are almost uncanny. Because of this, the Red Wings offer up some lessons for the Canucks. One of which is that, whatever one’s opinion on the Canucks’ various decisions thus far in their own rebuild, there have definitely been some worse decisions available. Detroit has made that obvious enough.
The parallels go as far back as last season and include two captains, Quinn Hughes and Dylan Larkin. For all the warts of the previous Patrik Allvin/Jim Rutherford regime, they at the very least eventually anticipated that Hughes wanted to be elsewhere and traded him before any requests became official, landing Zeev Buium, Marco Rossi, Liam Öhgren, and a pick that turned into Adam Novotný in the exchange. In one move, the Canucks supercharged their future stocks, and also avoided some unpleasant alternate outcomes.
To be entirely fair, the Red Wings were put in a tougher position by Dylan Larkin. For one, he was and is under contract until 2031, so he didn’t have any sort of built-in deadline for decision-making like Hughes, whose contract expires this year, did. Larkin’s desire to be elsewhere also came more out of the blue, and came in the form of a direct trade request. That happened back in April, but for a variety of reasons, the Red Wings still haven’t actually dealt Larkin. He was instead stripped of his captaincy. He started this current season injured, returned to a regular chorus of boos, and eventually took himself out of the lineup to await a trade. He’s since been suspended without pay by the team, and the situation has turned rather ugly.
In that interim between the Canucks trading Hughes in December 2025 and Larkin requesting his own trade in April 2026, the teams headed in opposite directions in the standings. The Canucks tanked and tanked hard, finishing in last place by a long shot and securing a top-three draft pick, which they used on Caleb Malhotra. The Red Wings, on the other hand, made yet another push toward the fringe of the postseason, ultimately missing the playoffs by seven points. That would have left the Wings with the 15th overall pick, but they’d already traded it to St. Louis in exchange for Justin Faulk – part of that ill-advised push for the playoffs. The pick wound up in Anaheim after the Mason McTavish trade and was used on Nikita Klepov, who already saw NHL action earlier this year.
So, at the end of the season, neither team made the playoffs, and both decided to move on from their current general managers. But the Canucks made the decision quick, firing Patrik Allvin on April 17. His replacement, Ryan Johnson, would be hired less than a month later, on May 14.
The Red Wings, on the other hand, dragged their feet on a decision with Steve Yzerman, ultimately allowing him to ‘resign’ into a senior adviser role on July 15. That was more than two months after the Canucks had already completed their own GM search.
The Red Wings’ search for a new GM lingered on, and on, and on. In fact, it never ended. After an offseason in which the uncertainty surrounding and then direct lack of a GM prevented them from making any moves of consequence – save for the consequential move they didn’t make that we’re about to get to – the Red Wings never really reached a decision. They waited until the eve of Training Camp before naming Shawn Horcoff their interim GM on September 15. Horcoff reportedly does not have the full authority of a regular GM and must have his work approved by owner and CEO Chris Ilitch. This lack of organizational clarity is a problem in and of itself, but it’s also led to one particularly negative outcome already, and one that contrasts especially sharply with the Canucks.
The Canucks and Red Wings both found themselves in possession of a young defender of enormous hype. For the Canucks, it was Buium, acquired in the Hughes trade after being selected by the Minnesota Wild at 12th overall in the 2024 Entry Draft. For the Red Wings, it was Simon Edvinsson, whom they drafted themselves at sixth overall in 2021. Both defenders were nearing the end of their contracts, with Edvinsson’s expiring into RFA status this summer and Buium’s set to do the same next summer.
Now, there’s plenty of debate to be had about who is the more valuable player here. Edvinsson has been around for longer and has definitely shown more at the NHL level thus far. But there’s no real debate to be had about who handled their asset better.
The Canucks made extending Buium a priority, extending him to an eight-year, $9.38 million contract. While there was some initial sticker shock on this deal – that’s been made a little more apparent by Buium’s up-and-down start to the 2026-27 season – most project it to age well, and it fits in fine with the new standard for RFA contracts in the NHL.
The Red Wings, meanwhile, could have extended Edvinsson as far back as July 1, 2025. Had they done so, they almost certainly would have gotten themselves a contract that would have aged well, as salaries hadn’t quite begun to skyrocket yet by that point. But outgoing GM Yzerman didn’t do that, and then the Red Wings spent this last offseason without a GM, so they couldn’t extend Edvinsson.
Edvinsson showed his dedication to his organization all the same by showing up to Training Camp and participating without a contract. But when a contract didn’t materialize even after Interim GM Horcoff took office, Edvinsson and his team eventually changed their tune. He went back to Sweden and let it be known that he’d now prefer a trade out of town.
That situation has carried on, and on, and on to a now outright uncomfortable degree. The Red Wings are rapidly approaching a December 1 deadline, at which point an unsigned Edvinsson becomes ineligible to return for the 2026-27 season. As of this writing, that’s fewer than two weeks away.
Most now believe that the Red Wings are going to not only be forced to trade Edvinsson, but to trade him under the pressure of that deadline. That’s not a recipe for a great return, and this has the makings of a major fumbling of an asset.
Speaking of this current 2026-27 season, the Red Wings aren’t even tanking properly. They’re once again in that mushy middle, eight points back of a playoff spot and yet eight points ahead of the Canucks in last place. Whatever the Red Wings want out of this season, they’re almost certainly not going to get it.
The parallels should be obvious by now. The Canucks traded their captain at a reasonable time and got back a haul. The Red Wings had to strip and suspend their own captain, and still haven’t gotten back a single asset for him as he sits on the sidelines. The Canucks hired Johnson as their GM and got the rebuild officially underway; the Red Wings still haven’t hired Yzerman’s replacement and have left Horcoff shorthanded as the interim. The Canucks drafted a top prospect in Malhotra at the top of the first round (and another later in the round in Novotný), and the Red Wings had already dealt their own first away. The Canucks got Buium under a long-term contract, and the Red Wings appear to have frittered Edvinsson all the way away.
Whatever one’s opinion on the state of the Canucks’ rebuild thus far, no one can say they’ve made the worst possible decisions along the way. We know this now because the worst possible decisions were already made by the Detroit Red Wings.
Sponsored by bet365
Daily FaceoffPuckPedia