A Graphic Guide to Succeeding at the NHL Draft

Ah, the NHL draft. A time of anxious anticipation.

But we’ve got you, er, covered.

To help you budding GMs out there, we at Canucks Army have prepared a handy list of do’s and don’ts for a successful draft. Thanks to @joshweissbock and @MoneyPuck_ for help compiling these tips. Ah, who am I kidding. They came up with them, I just added the witty remarks.

But enough foreplay, let’s get to the action.

Photo 2015-06-26, 6 18 45 AM

1. Don’t draft over-agers

Yeah, I’m looking at you, Mike Gillis. Look, it’s great to think you’re seeing something in these kids that nobody else has, but if they’ve been passed over in the draft for a couple of years already, you probably aren’t. What you probably are seeing is a man playing among boys. Wait, that sounds wrong. But you know what I meant. Age, size and experience make a huge difference in the junior leagues. Don’t be fooled into thinking this represents any kind of skill advantage.

Photo 2015-06-26, 6 18 50 AM

2. Do draft players that succeed against their peers

It’s great to have the tools, but unless a player has demonstrated that he can put them together and use them to succeed, take a pass. You want guys that have shown they can stand out against their peers.

Photo 2015-06-26, 6 18 55 AM

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

3. Don’t draft solely based on size

And when I say, players that stand out against their peers I don’t mean they’re tall. Size is great. Size is an asset. But don’t pick solely based on size. That’s how you wind up with Alex Stojanov and Libor Polasek. Size can be deceiving, especially at such a young age where the size differences can be, uh, huge.

Photo 2015-06-26, 6 19 00 AM

4. Don’t draft stay-at-home defensemen

Just don’t. “Stay-at-home” is just code for big and slow. Do draft puck moving defensemen that might not have the same offensive upside as some others. There is more to playing defense than standing in front of your net and clearing out opposing forwards. You need to be able to retrieve pucks and get them out of danger. Sure, having a scoring touch would be nice, but not everybody can be Erik Karlsson. You want mobile guys that can get the puck out of the zone and make a good first pass to transition the offense. If you’re really hung up on those big lumbering defensemen of yesteryear, there are plenty available in free agency.

Photo 2015-06-26, 6 19 05 AM

5. Do draft players that can score. A lot.

You can teach defense and positioning. You can’t teach offensive skill and the knack for finding open ice. The point of a hockey game is to score goals. Draft players that have shown they can do that on a consistent basis, i.e. be aware of outlandish shooting percentages. Don’t get me wrong, keeping the puck out of your own net is important too. But one-dimensional players that specialize in that are a lot cheaper on the free agent or trade market. Look around the NHL and you’ll that contract values correlate very well with point production. You want those good, offensive players on an entry-level or RFA contract during their prime production years. The only way to get them is through the draft.

Advertisement - Continue Commenting Below

Photo 2015-06-26, 6 19 10 AM

6. Don’t waste picks on goalies

At least not in the first three rounds or so. Look, there is very little difference in goalie performance at the NHL level these days. In fact, some analyses have shown that replacement level is league average. In other words, a replacement level goalie from the minors would likely perform at league average save percentage. Sure, getting an elite level goalie like Price or Lundqvist would be great. But so would winning the lottery. But that doesn’t mean you should spend your entire paycheque on lottery tickets. That’s what those spare change picks in the later rounds are for.

Photo 2015-06-26, 6 19 14 AM

7. Do pick players with a history of success

Let me turn that old saying around: those who do not repeat history are doomed to regret it. Don’t be fooled by small sample sizes or players riding the percentages. If you’re going to take a chance on someone, make it somebody with a history of success at every level they’ve played and across seasons. On average, it is way more likely that an individual player will have a luck-driven season than he is to make the NHL as a regular. So look for that consistency of performance across seasons.

By the way, this works on the down side as well. Don’t be fooled by a bad season during their draft year that might due to luck, injury, teammates, etc. Don’t overlook a history of success and succumb to recency bias.

Photo 2015-06-26, 6 19 18 AM

8. Do take quality of teammates into account

Who you play with matters. If you’re on the best team in the NHL, playing with last year’s high end picks, it will have an impact on your performance. So if you can’t score when surrounded by good players, that should be a warning sign. Similarly, if you’re putting up insane number playing with scrubs, there’s probably something there. Look beyond the numbers at some of the other factors that might have affected them either way.

Photo 2015-06-26, 6 19 23 AM

9. Do draft players from European pro leagues

This is the flip side to No. 1. Players that don’t look out of place playing with and against professionals that are bigger, stronger and with more experience are that much more likely to make it in the NHL. That’s not to say that you should rush junior age players along, but if you have one taking a regular shift in the Swedish Elite League, for example, then you need to take that into account when looking at his numbers in comparison to someone playing against kids in the North American junior leagues.

Photo 2015-06-26, 6 19 27 AM

10. Don’t settle for the “safe” pick

Don’t take a player just because he is “NHL ready”. Again, that is usually just code for big. Look for players that have a high upside potential. Safe picks are more likely than not going to wind up as depth players. Yes, they’re important, but you don’t need to waste draft picks on them. You can pick them up as known quantities as free agents, through trades, or heck, even on waivers. They’re a dime $12-15 million a dozen, for God’s sake. As mentioned earlier, draft picks are like lottery tickets; the draft is a game of chance. The way to evaluate games of chance is to calculate the expected value by multiplying the potential value by the probability of success. We know from looking at draft history that the probability of success is pretty low, even for so-called “safe” picks. So your best bet is to go for players with that high upside value. Sure, you might be a little less likely to hit a winner, but if you do, it will actually be somebody that can make a difference.



So there you have it. Follow these handy tips and you should be back on the road to rebuild your troubled franchise in not time at all.

Now, for extra fun, you can turn the draft into a drinking game by throwing back a shot of tequila every time Jim Benning breaks one of these rules over the next two days. And on the off chance he breaks more than one with an individual pick, well drink accordingly.



You can also check out the monthly collections of Graphic Comments over at The Sporting News.

  • wojohowitz

    Too bad there`s not an open thread on todays events.

    Here`s a couple of thoughts; Lehner looks like he has a lot of upside at 23. The question is how durable he is – can he play a full season? He played only 47 games with SSM in junior. 40 games in one season in the AHL and only 36 with Ottawa. He`s not a proven number one but Buffalo thinks he will be. Can he handle the workload?

    Hamilton looks like a second coming of Bouwmeester. Big and soft. Drives his coach crazy. Very capable but doesn`t stand up for his team mates.

  • andyg

    So now one team is gone in goaltender sweepstakes….

    Wonder if Benning will pull a Gillis and over play his hand? If Talbot goes next and he has to drop asking price, then trade Markstrom for whatever you can get. Keep Lack and play Miller and Lack as a tandem. Lack has proven he can handle that situation and could get more for him at the trade deadline….

    Trading Lack for a low 3rd/4th is not worth it.

  • wojohowitz

    That was one of the best articles about Draft Day I have ever read.
    Taking tip # 8 into account, subconsciously, I didn’t want the Leafs to take Dylan Strome. I feel in the top 10 picks, he is the one that could end up being a “bust”. He be right along that diagonal dotted line, in the top-right corner.