Report: Alex Edler's Suspension for Staal Hit Could Extend into Sochi Games

Thomas Drance
May 18 2013 06:51PM

Alex Edler was functionally kicked out of the World Championship tournament for a brutal knee-on-knee hit on Canadian centre Eric Staal in the quarterfinal match between the Canadian team and the Tre Kronor on Thursday. Sweden won the game three-to-two in a shootout, and then defeated Finland's mens team on Saturday to advance to the finals.

On Saturday Eric Staal got some good medical news in that he won't require surgery, and is expected to be ready for the start of next season. Alex Edler, however, and perhaps deservedly, got some tough news on Saturday. The latest reports surfacing from Swedish media outlet Aftonbladet on Saturday afternoon suggest that Alex Edler's suspension may extend into the 2014 Olympic tournament in Sochi. National team manager Tommy Boutsedt even described Edler's punishment (via Google Translate) as "basically a lifetime ban."

Read past the jump.

Here's more from Aftonbladet on Edler's upcoming extended suspension (via google translate):

[The World Championship's] disciplinary committee has reviewed the situation and recommended the IIHF that the suspension will be extended by a further three games - which would mean that it also applies in next year's Olympics.

Tommy Boutsedt confirmed the Aftonbladet report, and added his two cents on the suspensions fairness (per google translate once again): "That's the message we have received from the IIHF now. And you can not take out players who are off to an Olympic tournament. It falls on its face. So five games."

I've seen a lot of people, universally Canucks fans, opine that Alex Edler was really trying to avoid hitting Staal on this play, and just spectacularly failed to do so which caused the knee-on-knee collision. Honestly, I've always believed that intent is a stupid way to adjudicate whether or not a hit is clean, or to what degree it's dangerous. This hit is a perfect example since I have no idea what Edler is trying to do on this play, and neither do you, but we should be able to agree that it doesn't really matter since the hit was both reckless and injurious. This is the sort of contact that can end a career (and has in the past), so a five game suspension seems like the least the IIHF can do.

But it does look like it'll cost Alex Edler a spot on the Swedish Olympic team. Edler, you may recall, was rather preposterously left off of the 2010 team in favour of world beaters like Douglas Murray, Matthias Ohlund and Henrik Tallinder. Unsurprisingly Sweden failed to medal in that tournament.

Going into the Sochi Olympics, the competition was already going to be steep for Alex Edler to earn a spot on the Swedish blue-line, what with the current surplus of talented young Swedish blueliners just totally dominating the NHL at the moment. With the likes of Oliver Ekman-Larrson, Johnny Oduya, Jonas Brodin, Victor Hedman, Tobias Enstrom, Nicklas Kronwall, Jonathan Ericsson, Carl Gunnarsson, Erik Karlsson and Nicklas Hjarlmarsson in the mix for the Tre Kronor, it would be very much understandable if there wasn't space for a player who probably won't be eligible to compete in the round robin stage of the tournament...

3136ae487fac57943f99a50e66e4d6cf
Thomas Drance lives in Toronto, eats spicy food and writes about hockey. He is an NHL News Editor at theScore, the ex-managing editor of CanucksArmy.com and an opinionated blowhard to boot. You can follow him on twitter @thomasdrance.
Avatar
#1 GRR
May 18 2013, 11:12PM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Props
0
props

It's too bad. I would think that Edler would have been a shoe-in for a top-4 role. Brodin may not quite be ready, and Oduya is a give-away machine.

I had Kronvwall-Karlsson Enstrom-Edler Hjalmarsson-Hedman as Sweden's top 6 with Ekman-Larsson as the 7th man. If they went with 8th forwards, Gunnarsson would slot in.

But I agree, why take a player that will miss half the tournament?

Avatar
#2 Canooks
May 19 2013, 12:00AM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Props
0
props

Good, at least Edler did something on the ice for a change. It would have been better if he got hurt instead of Staal, that way he cant cough up the puck in Edler fashion for the Canucks. the guys problem is that he always plays for the wrong team...what a goof. He should be working at Ikea, not playing pro hockey

Avatar
#3 Cale
May 19 2013, 04:16PM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Props
0
props

Edler hits like he plays defence: once a game, and usually by accident. It definitely deserved a suspension, but I can't see the argument that the suspension should extend to the olympics. I know you don't like intent as a measure of severity, Drance, but there's a difference between accidentally hitting someone who's crossing the street and intentionally mowing them down.

Suspensions that span multiple seasons/tournaments should be reserved for those infractions where the offending player clearly set out to hurt the victim (see: Bertuzzi, McSorely).

Comments are closed for this article.